Catholic University of Lublin fails to discipline professor over ritual murder claim

The Catholic University of Lublin (KUL) failed to take disciplinary action against a priest-professor who claimed that Jews have carried out ritual murder against Christians, on the grounds that this is “part of a still unsettled academic discussion.”

The statement in question was made by Father Tadeusz Guz, a professor at the KUL, Poland’s foremost Catholic university.  While giving a lecture in Warsaw in May 2018, he said: “We know that the facts of ritual murders cannot be erased from history…because we, the Polish state, have in our archives, in surviving documents, we have through the ages – when Jews lived together with our Polish nation – we have binding rulings after ritual murders.”

After Guz’s lecture, the Polish Council of Christians and Jews had formally protested against his “absolutely unacceptable” words.

“Accusations against Jews for ritually murdering Christians, although officially rejected by the church, unfortunately still return in the imagination of some Catholics,” wrote the Council. “We appeal to the archbishop and the rector  to take strict disciplinary measures against the person who advocates such anti-Jewish, but also anti-Catholic, statements,” they continued.

In response, the rector of KUL, Antoni Dębiński, and Lublin’s archbishop, Stanisław Budzik, released a statement saying that they found Guz’s statements to be “unacceptable”,  noting however that they had been made privately, outside of his work at the university.

Dębiński nevertheless referred the case to KUL’s disciplinary officer, who in October 2020, decided to discontinue proceedings.

Among the justifications for this decision, the relevant committee noted that Guz had been expressing “private views…outside the workplace”. It added that, while they “could be difficult for Jewish communities to accept, they were not slander or lies, but knowledge gained from academic analysis of available source materials”.

The committee also claimed that the issue in question is “part of a still unsettled academic discussion”. As such, Guz’s statement should be seen as “part of the academic discourse on this issue, which, it should be emphasised, still remains unresolved”.

This position was met with an angry response by Zygmunt  Stępiński, director of the POLIN Museum of the History of Polish Jews, who expressed “amazement and indignation” at the decision not to discipline Guz.

“[While] respecting the autonomy of the university, I cannot remain silent when the world receives a statement straight from The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, Nazi or Stalinist propaganda,” Stępiński  wrote. “Let me remind you that in the not-too-distant past, similar statements led directly to social unrest and bloodshed.”

“I must protest publicly and call on the university authorities to take a clear position on this matter,” added Stępiński, in his open letter to KUL’s new rector, Mirosław Kalinowski.

KUL’s decision was also condemned by the Never Again Association, a leading Polish anti-racism NGO. Its director, Rafał Pankowski, told the Algemeiner that Guz’s “whole lecture was antisemitic”.

Guz “argued that Jews as a community have failed God by not converting to Christianity”, that the Talmud was based on “lies”, and that Karl Marx was a “Jewish nationalist”, said Pankowski, who also noted that Guz has given antisemitic lectures in the past, including claiming that Jews financed Hitler and the Holocaust.

Conspiracy myths about ritual murder and kidnapping are still widely believed in Poland today. A survey conducted by the Centre for Research on Prejudice at the University of Warsaw in 2017 found that 24.5% of Poles agreed that “such kidnappings took place”. That figure had risen from 10.3% in 2009.

In a statement, the KUL declared: “Allegations of ritual murder against the followers of Judaism are unjustifiable and untrue. We strongly disagree with allegations of that sort. They are unfounded both in research and historical facts. The University holds the position expressed by the Popes condemning allegations of ritual murder.”

related

Subscribe to EJC newsletter

Get EJC's bi-weekly newsletter, including the latest statements and news from the European Jewish communities, direct to your inbox.

European Jewish Congress will use the information you provide on this form to contact you. We will treat your information with respect and will not share it with others. By clicking Subscribe, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.

Statements

EJC expresses support for Israel as it is being attacked

The European Jewish Congress (EJC) expresses its full solidarity with our brothers and sisters in Israel as the country continues to suffer rocket bombardment and attacks from Hamas terrorists.

EJC says latest rise in far-Right incidents in Germany should raise alarm

The European Jewish Congress expresses alarm at the latest figures released by German Interior Minister Horst Seehofer which show that the number of crimes committed by far-Right extremists in Germany rose last year to its highest level since WWII.

EJC mourns Mount Meron tragedy victims

The European Jewish Congress and all its communities are deeply shocked and saddened to learn of the terrible tragedy at the tomb of Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai at Mount Meron in Israel, where thousands of people had gathered to celebrate Lag Ba’Omer.

EJC applauds European Parliament decision to censure UNRWA over Antisemitism in its textbooks

The EJC welcomes and applauds the European Parliament’s resolution expressing concern at the “hate speech and violence taught in Palestinian schools” run by the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA).